Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Harrowing Tales of Death and Destruction in Brgy. Baño, Arayat
















“Bigla pong may narinig kaming ingay. Tapos nakita na namin yung bato at putik na umaagos. Dun po nakita yung magkapatid na namatay na magkayakap. Yakap-yakap nila yung kanilang alkansiya. Dun naman po nakita yung buntis. Kung di po kami nakalabas sa bintana, siguro patay na rin kaming lahat na magpapamilya ngayon.”
(We heard a loud noise. In an instant, boulders and mud were flowing towards our homes. Rescuers found the bodies of two siblings who were locked in a tight embrace in that house. They were embracing a coin bank. The body of the pregnant woman was found there. Had we not been able to rush out of the our house through the window, we, too would have perished.)

Teener Jay-an Apudaca could hardly stop once he started telling his stories about the harrowing experience of death and destruction in the small barangay of Bano, Arayat, Pampanga. His face was devoid of any emotion. Words just kept pouring out of his mouth as he recounted the horror of the landslide that occurred on Saturday, September 26 at the height of Typhoon Ondoy’s fury which dumped 455 mm. of rainfall over a 24- hour period. PAG-ASA says the last time this occurred was in 1967 albeit at a lesser volume of 335 mm.

Jay-an and his family are now among the hundreds of evacuees staying at the Arayat National Park. They have nowhere to go, nothing they can call their own except the shirts on their backs. Residents of Brgy. Bano say that it was normal for floodwater to pass through their barangay from upstream. But this occurrence, this landslide totally caught them by surprise. “Did Mt. Arayat erupt? Or was it caused by illegal mining?” they ask, torn between shock and disbelief at what occurred high noon of Saturday. At least 12 persons died from the Bano landslide. Among them were members of the dela Cruz, Portacio, and Galang families.

“The children were watching TV. Then we heard their screams and shouts for help. By then, it was too late to help them because mud was rushing in at an unbelievable speed,” adds Jay-an. The proverbial sound of thousands of horses galloping in a rampage, along with creaking sounds that seemed to emanate from the core of the earth brought back memories of the Pinatubo disaster that devastated Pampanga in 1991. The center of destruction then was Bacolor and its neighboring municipalities.

Jay-an was one of the barangay folks who chanced upon the volunteers of Holy Rosary Parish-Social Action Center as they surveyed the damage caused by the landslide. Like the others, he was walking around what used to be a neighborhood of simple folks, all gone now to reside temporarily at the evacuation center. Muddied clothes, shoes, books, and remains of nipa houses littered the area, along with stones and boulders of various shapes and sizes. The ground was still wet and slippery when the HRP-SAC volunteers came on Tuesday to deliver a truckload of relief goods to the Parish of St. Catherine for the affected families in Arayat. With them were staff members of the Holy Angel University – Office for Community Extension Services (HAU-OCES) who came with an initial donation of goods, too from their academic community. The Social Action Center of Pampanga (SACOP) has, likewise, been monitoring the disaster and mobilizing resources for distribution among the affected parishes of the Archdiocese of San Fernando.

Learning of the situation in Arayat in the afternoon of September 27, Holy Rosary Parish Priest Bp. Pablo S. David and other priests assigned at the said parish immediately issued an appeal to Sunday mass-goers for donations in cash and in kind. Grateful, perhaps, for having been spared from the floodings, Angeleños/as responded overwhelmingly and with urgency filling the convent grounds with relief goods including old clothes, mats, blankets, slippers, instant noodles, canned goods, biscuits, candies, rice and medicines.

The first batch of relief goods was dispatched on Tuesday morning, September 29, with more to follow for other parishes needing assistance. Fr. Rey Cruz, Parish Priest of St. Catherine Parish received the goods in behalf of the parish community. The HRP-SAC volunteers were, then, brought to the affected areas including Brgy. Cupang where a portion of the protective earth dike (Arnedo Dike) is near breaching point as water continues to scour the sides and erode the soil. The Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) has been rushing to fortify the dike through sandbagging with the help of residents. The dike protects Arayat town proper and neighboring towns from floods.

Barangay Baño, where the landslide occurred, used to be a popular destination among local tourists who came to bathe in the lukewarm waters of the Arayat National Park which boasted of a spring, a waterfall, and a legendary 100-step stairs leading to the top of the majestic Mt. Arayat. Nowadays, it has become a popular destination among mediamen and good Samaritans who come to visit the site of the landslide to gather information or extend a helping hand.

The Provincial Disaster Coordinating Council of Pampanga reported on Sunday that 190 barangays in 20 municipalities and 1 city were flooded. By Monday, the number rose to 236 barangays in 18 municipalities and 1 city. The whole of Angeles City was spared from flooding and destruction.

Monitoring of the situation in Pampanga continues as two weather disturbances threaten to occur within this week even as Central Luzon and Metro Manila residents have yet to recover from the ill effects of Typhoon Ondoy.

Updates from Pampanga re: Tropical Storm Ondoy (as of September 29, 2009)

Tropical Storm PARMA (PRE-PEPENG) rapidly gained strength...now a Category 1 Typhoon...currently showing a pin-hole EYE as it prepares to enter the Philippine Area of Responsibility (PAR).

*Residents and visitors along the east of coast of Luzon, Philippines should closely monitor the progress of PARMA.

Forecast Outlook: PARMA is expected to enter PAR late this afternoon and track NW'ly w/in the next 12 to 24 hours and intensify. The 2 to 5-day Long-Range Forecast shows the system turning more to the WNW across the Philippine Sea as it reaches Category 3 strength with winds of more than 200 kph and a distance of about 565 km. NE of Metro Naga/CWC. PARMA shall be about 230 km. NE of Batanes Islands on Monday, Oct 5 - as it approaches the SE coast of Taiwan. Please be aware that long-range forecast changes every now and then. Continued monitoring on this potential typhoon is a must for disaster preparedness agencies.

Tropical Storm 18W (UNNAMED) to pass near Guam any moment from now...Gale-force winds w/ rains expected.

+ Forecast Outlook: 18W is expected to remain a weak system as it passes very close to Guam. The 2 to 3-day Medium-Range forecast shows the system dissipating and being absorbed into the circulation of Typhoon PARMA, which is a much stronger system.

Massive flooding occurred last Saturday, September 26 across Metro Manila, Southern Tagalog Provinces and Central Luzon. PAGASA Science Garden in Quezon City recorded a new record rainfall accumulation of 455 mm (17.9 inches) in 24 hours, erasing the previous record of 335 mm (13.2 inches) which fell in June 1967.

- 249 barangays from 17 municipalities and 1 city are flooded. Landslide reported in San Juan Bano, Arayat.
- Damage to infrastructure estimated at P 123,200,000.00
- Damage to agriculture estimated at P 270,228,810.50

Affected municipalities include:

1. Guagua – 31 barangays
- Affected Families – 19,783
- Affected Individuals – 98,934
- No. of individuals in evacuation centers – 117 at Lambac Elementary School

2. Candaba – 10 barangays
- as per PNP report, negative evacuation as of today

3. City of San Fernando – 2 barangays

4. Sta. Rita – 3 barangays

5. Sto. Tomas – 7 barangays

6. Apalit – 10 barangays
- Affected Families – 2,680

7. Sasmuan – 12 barangays
- Affected Families – 3,925
- Affected individuals – 19,625

8. Lubao – 29 barangays
- Affected Families – 10,025
- Affected individuals – 38,682

9. Mexico – 5 barangays
- Affected Families – 2,115 (All roads passable except the third street of Parian)

10. Floridablanca – 13 barangays
- Affected Families – 1,800
- Affected individuals – 9,000

11. Sta. Ana – 13 barangays
- Affected Families – 5,805
- Affected individuals – 24,965
- No. of individuals in evacuation centers - 141

12. San Luis – 11 barangays
- Affected Families – 2,377
- Affected individuals – 12,781

13. Masantol – 26 barangays
- Affected Families – 7,690
- Affected Individuals – 36,047
- No. of individuals in evacuation centers – 229 individuals (24 at Alauli Chapel, 75 at the Brgy. Hall of Sagrada, 50 at the Day Care Center of San Isidro Anak, 80 at Puti Elementary School)

14. Macabebe – 26 barangays
- No of Affected Families – 8,496
- No. of Affected Individuals – 43,657

15. Minalin – 15 barangays
- Affected Families – 4,339
- Affected individuals – 24,834

16. San Simon – 13 barangays
- Affected Families – 6,197
- Affected individuals – 28,283

17. Magalang – 10 barangays
- Affected Families – 6,384
- Affected individuals – 59,546

18. Arayat – 13 barangays
- Affected Families – 1,661
- Affected Individuals – 5,896

Arayat Landslide:

No. of Affected Families – 256
No. of Affected Individuals – 768
No. of individuals in evacuation centers – 625 (San Juan Bano Central Elem. School – 295, Anderson Elem. School – 330)

Casualties from the Arayat landslide:

1. Riza Portacio
2. Sonny Boy Portacio
3. Manilyn Portacio
4. Liza Portacio
5. Mackmack Galang
6. Catalina dela Cruz
7. Mary Anne dela Cruz
8. Marlon dela Cruz
9. Popoy dela Cruz
10. Shirley dela Cruz
11. Marilyn dela Cruz
12. Marco Galang

The Holy Rosary Parish – Social Action Center (HRP-SAC, 2nd Flr. of the Holy Rosary Parish Hall; Cellphone No. 0928-520-7485; Landline – 625-91-43) and the Social Action Center of Pampanga (SACOP, Maimpis, City of San Fernando, Pampanga; Tel. No. 961-41-12 or 860-53-38) are accepting donations in cash or in kind for distribution among the affected families.


Sources:

Provincial Disaster Coordinating Council - Pampanga (Tel No. 860-55-83)
http://www.maybagyo.com/

Monday, September 28, 2009

Updates from Pampanga re: Tropical Storm Ondoy (as of September 28, 2009)

Typhoon KETSANA (ONDOY) approaching Category 2 strength as it rapidly intensifies...endangers Southern Hainan and Vietnam.It is expected to continue moving West and shall reach the coast of Vietnam tomorrow morning. Landfall is likely along Central Vietnam near the City of Hue tomorrow afternoon. The 2-day Short-Range Forecast shows the system dissipating rapidly along Laos on Wednesday Sep 30.

Massive flooding occurred last Saturday across Metro Manila, Southern Tagalog Provinces and Central Luzon. PAGASA Science Garden in Quezon City recorded a new record rainfall accumulation of 455 mm (17.9 inches) in 24 hours, erasing the previous record of 335 mm (13.2 inches) which fell in June 1967.

- 236 barangays from 18 municipalities and 1 city are flooded. Landslide reported in San Juan Bano, Arayat.
- Damage to infrastructure estimated at P 123,200,000.00
- Damage to agriculture estimated at P 270,228,810.50

Affected municipalities include:

1. Guagua – 31 barangays
- Affected Families – 19,783
- Affected Individuals – 98,934
- No. of individuals in evacuation centers – 117 at Lambac Elementary School

2. Candaba – 10 barangays
- No. of families in evacuation centers – 20 families at Earth Park, Mandasig

3. Porac – 4 barangays

4. City of San Fernando – 6 barangays

5. Mabalacat – 4 barangays
- Affected Families – 20
- Affected individuals - 100

6. Sta. Rita – 3 barangays

7. Sto. Tomas – 7 barangays

8. Apalit – 7 barangays
- Affected Families – 1,460


9. Sasmuan – 12 barangays
- Affected Families – 3,925
- Affected individuals – 19,625

10. Lubao – 29 barangays
- Affected Families – 10,025
- Affected individuals – 38,682

11. Mexico – 11 barangays
- Affected Families – 2,115 (All roads passable except the third street of Parian)

12. Floridablanca – 13 barangays
- Affected Families – 1,800
- Affected individuals – 9,000

13. Sta. Ana – 14 barangays
- Affected Families – 6,105
- Affected individuals – 26,377
- No. of individuals in evacuation centers - 141

14. San Luis – 11 barangays
- Affected Families – 2,377
- Affected individuals – 12,781

15. Masantol – 26 barangays
- Affected Families – 1,230
- No. of families in evacuation centers – 15 families at the Brgy. Hall of Sagrada, 10 families at the Brgy. Hall & Day Care of San Isidro Anak, 16 families at Puti Elementary School

16. Macabebe – 10 barangays

17. Minalin – 15 barangays
- Affected Families – 4,339
- Affected individuals – 24,834

18. San Simon – 13 barangays
- Affected Families – 4,698
- Affected individuals – 23,254

19. Magalang – 10 barangays
- Affected Families – 6,384
- Affected individuals – 59,546


Arayat Landslide:

No. of Affected Families – 211
No. of Affected Individuals – 985
No. of individuals in evacuation centers – 985 (San Juan Bano Elem. School – 597, Anderson Elem. School – 152, Plazang Luma – 236)

Casualties from the Arayat landslide:

1. Riza Portacio
2. Sonny Boy Portacio
3. Manilyn Portacio
4. Liza Portacio
5. Mackmack Galang
6. Catalina dela Cruz
7. Mary Anne dela Cruz
8. Marlon dela Cruz
9. Popoy dela Cruz
10. Shirley dela Cruz
11. Marilyn dela Cruz
12. Marco Galang


The Holy Rosary Parish – Social Action Center (HRP-SAC, 2nd Flr. of the Holy Rosary Parish Hall; Cellphone No. 0928-520-7485; Landline – 625-91-42) and the Social Action Center of Pampanga (SACOP, Maimpis, City of San Fernando, Pampanga; Tel. No. 961-41-12 or 860-53-38) are accepting donations in cash or in kind for distribution among the affected families.

+ Forecast Outlook: Tropical Depression 19W (PRE-PEPENG) heading west towards Yap and Ulithi Islands in Western Micronesia.19W is expected to continue moving due West for the next 2 days, reaching Tropical Storm status tomorrow afternoon and shall enter the Philippine Area of Responsibility (PAR) by Wednesday morning, Sep 30. The 3 to 5-day Long-Range Forecast shows the system turning abruptly WNW to NW-ward, becoming a Category 1 Typhoon while about 500 km. to the east of Camarines Sur on Friday afternoon Oct 02. It shall be about 300 km to the east of Cagayan Province in Northern Luzon on Saturday afternoon, October 3. Please be aware that long-range forecast changes every now and then. Continued monitoring on this potential typhoon is a must for disaster preparedness agencies.

+ Forecast Outlook: Tropical Depression 18W (UNNAMED) now starting to move West. 18W is expected to start tracking WNW and intensify into a Tropical Storm. The 2 to 5-day Long-Range forecast shows the system continuing moving WNW, passing very close to the south of Guam by Wednesday afternoon Sep 30. 18W shall enter the Philippine Area of Responsibility (PAR) on Friday afternoon, Oct 2nd and then turn more on a near-westerly track across the Philippine Sea on Saturday Oct 03, threatening Northern Luzon. Please be aware that long-range forecast changes every now and then. Continued monitoring on this potential typhoon is a must for disaster preparedness agencies.



Sources:

Provincial Disaster Coordinating Council - Pampanga (Tel No. 860-55-83)
http://www.maybagyo.com/

Friday, September 18, 2009

Stage 1 of Pampanga Recount Over, COMELEC to Set Hearings Soon

PPCRV Recount Monitoring Report 3
September 17, 2009
Contact: PPCRV Secretariat at Tel. Nos. 860-53-38 or 961-41-12


The Commission on Elections (COMELEC), on Wednesday (September 16, 2009), wrapped up work on the physical count (which is stage 1 of the recount process involving sorting and classifying ballots and recording claims/objections) as the remaining 104 of the 4,839 ballot boxes were opened for revision.

As text messages containing figures and claiming victory for former Board Member Lilia Pineda started circulating on Wednesday, 2nd Division Presiding Commissioner Nicodemo T. Ferrer reiterated his earlier statement that, “At this point, we do not know who is going to prevail. The COMELEC is not bound by press releases but by concrete evidence.” He admitted that this particular case had the biggest number of revision committees because time had been running out. The most number of committees ever created for a recount was 10 to 12 partly because of limited space at the COMELEC office in Intramuros, Manila.

In a meeting with representatives of the Parish Pastoral Council for Responsible Voting (PPCRV-Pampanga) and the Holy Rosary Parish-Social Action Center (HRP-SAC), Comm. Ferrer stated that the Pampanga recount case will be resolved before the 2010 elections (although a definite time frame has not be set and will largely depend on the hearings and motions to be filed). He added that the COMELEC will not allow any party to delay the process any further and will instill discipline in the court hearings that are expected to start after the reports have been submitted and reviewed. The twenty one (21) revision committees have 10 days (from the end of the physical recount) to submit their consolidated committee reports for review of the COMELEC 2nd Division before the court hearings are set.

The Pampanga Recount stemmed from an election protest filed last May 25, 2007 by losing gubernatorial candidate Lilia Pineda against Gov. Eddie Panlilio on allegations of mis-appreciation and misreading of ballots and fraud and irregularities. The case reached the Supreme Court which issued an order stopping the COMELEC from retrieving the ballot boxes - an order that was lifted last July 15, 2009 paving the way for a recount that started on August 12, 2009.

All ballot boxes from Pampanga (excluding those of Angeles City) were immediately retrieved and brought to the COMELEC warehouse at the Maxi-lite Bldg. in U.N. Avenue for safekeeping until the physical recount could be completed. Juanito Roño, COMELEC-employed Custodian stationed at the warehouse revealed that three sets of security forces including the COMELEC’s ECAD (Electoral Contest Adjudication Department), an organic security force and the Special Action Force (SAF) have joined forces to provide ample security and protect the integrity of the ballots.

“This is part of democracy; everybody is entitled to due process,” said Comm. Ferrer as he urged the public to ‘at least presume that we are honest unless proven otherwise’ in the midst of controversies surrounding the Pampanga recount case. “Give us the benefit of the doubt,” he appealed as he recounted that the COMELEC has always been blamed by losing candidates and their supporters after each election. “Let’s give automation a try this coming 2010 elections instead of conjuring scenarios that sow fear and panic among the people,” he added.

Revision Process

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Recount Status as of September 9, 2009

COMELEC TO WRAP UP PHYSICAL RECOUNT IN A WEEK’S TIME







Long tables and benches occupied by twenty one revision committees fill the lobbies and the corridors of the 7th and 8th floors of the Palacio del Gobernador in Intramuros. The now familiar sight of yellow ballot boxes with masking tape seals and padlocks litter the hallway, some waiting to be picked up for the revision and some with the “Revised” label waiting to be hauled back to the warehouse.

The revisors are hard at work – sorting and segregating the ballots, opening the ballot boxes with the help of a wrench, examining the condition of the boxes and the documents contained therein, recording the observations, writing reports, photocopying contested ballots, etc. Once in a while, they briefly lift their gaze to welcome visitors and guests with inquisitive looks or cheerful greetings.

Such is the atmosphere at the COMELEC office, site of the on-going physical recount of ballots. As Kapampangans wait with bated breaths for the outcome of the on-going recount of the gubernatorial votes (Lilia Pineda vs. Eddie Panlilio, filed on May 25, 2007), the COMELEC office in Intramuros, Manila hums with activity in a bid to beat the 45-day timeframe set for the completion of the physical recount process.

True to its commitment to monitor the recount process and give factual information to the public, the Parish Pastoral Council for Responsible Voting (PPCRV-Pampanga) sent four representatives to the COMELEC office on Wednesday, September 9, 2009 to document the recount process and hold an audience with Hon. Nicodemo T. Ferrer, Presiding Officer of the COMELEC 2nd Division for updates.

“We have a week to go before we wrap up on the physical recount,” said Comm. Ferrer. He pointed out that this is 10 to 15 days less than the original target of 45 days. The recount of Pampanga votes started on August 12, 2009 after the Supreme Court en Banc ordered the COMELEC to proceed with the recount in a ruling issued last July 15, 2009. (Please see attached Status of Recount).

Comm. Ferrer explained that when Gov. Panlilio filed a motion to suspend the recount for a few weeks due to lack of funds to pay for his revisors, the COMELEC responded by speeding up the process to cut down on the number of days and, hence, on cost. Panlilio’s camp responded by appealing to its revisors for a little sacrifice to allow them to decrease the daily allowance from P550 to P 300 per day, a move that has allowed Panlilio to continue sending revisors.

Comm. Ferrer emphasized that at this point, it is impossible for anybody to know how the COMELEC will rule on the case. This runs contrary to earlier news reports that Pineda was winning in the recount and would assume office as Governor of Pampanga before the year ends. Both Comm. Ferrer and Atty. Allen Francis Abaya, Clerk of Court of the COMELEC 2nd Division assured the public that both parties will be given a fair chance to prove and disprove allegations based on concrete evidence to be presented during the hearings.

The two COMELEC officials added that after the physical recount, a legal battle is expected to ensue between the parties (Pineda and Panlilio) to assert their positions – a battle that may reach the Supreme Court. Following the physical revision of the ballots, the Clerk of Court will collate individual reports from each of the twenty one committees for submission to the 2nd Division which is composed of the following Commissioners: Hon. Nicodemo T. Ferrer (who succeeded Comm. Florentino Tuason and Rene Sarmiento as Presiding Officer of the 2nd Division); Hon. Lucenito N. Tagle and Hon. Elias R. Yusoph. The 2nd Division will then set hearings, examine the reports and the contested ballots and review the evidences presented by both parties before coming up with a resolution on the case. Motions and counter-motions could be filed with the COMELEC en banc and appeals could be filed with the Supreme Court later.

When asked about the pending disqualification case filed by Averell Laquindanum against Lilia Pineda for vote-buying, Comm. Ferrer stated that its outcome will not, in any way, affect the recount case. He added that the disqualification case which stems from an alleged election offense was re-raffled and is now handled by the 1st Division. It was revealed that the ponente is currently in the process of penning a resolution on the case.

“We appreciate organizations like the PPCRV which help us reach out to voters (so that they will be aware of what is going on),” said Comm Ferrer. “In protest cases such as this, people are usually suspicious of what we are doing. It causes unnecessary tension,” he added, noting that this is a celebrated case that is closely followed by the media and the people. He appealed to the lawyers of both parties to “help us do our job well instead of causing confusion by issuing premature claims”.

Monday, September 7, 2009

PPCRV Holds Public Forum on the Pampanga Recount

“Your presence will mean a lot. You should be ready to sacrifice.” Thus, said Commission on Elections (COMELEC) Commissioner Rene V. Sarmiento as he encouraged Kapampangans to be more vigilant and diligent in monitoring the recount process.

Speaking at a Public Forum on the Recount held last September 5, 2009 (Saturday) at the University of the Assumption Auditorium, Commissioner Sarmiento explained the on-going recount process that stemmed from an election protest filed on May 25, 2007 by losing gubernatorial candidate Lilia “Baby” Pineda against incumbent Pampanga Governor Eddie Panlilio.

The Public Forum was organized by the Parish Pastoral Council for Responsible Voting (PPCRV) – Pampanga and the Archdiocese of San Fernando (ASF)-Pampanga in response to a clamor for accurate information and guidance on the raging recount issue which Panlilio supporters tagged as a “moral issue” and a “threat to democracy in Pampanga”.

Citing Section 255 of the Omnibus Election Code of 1985 (OEC) as the legal basis for the recount, Commissioner Sarmiento emphasized that the COMELEC is just an implementor of the law, as mandated by the Philippine Constitution which provides that “election contests will be under the exclusive jurisdiction of the COMELEC.” If we are after electoral reforms, then we should start with legal reforms,” said Commissioner Sarmiento as he pointed out that OEC is 24 years old and needs to be reviewed and amended to make it more relevant to modern times.

The forum was attended by 337 representatives from various civil society organizations, church-based groups, academe, youth groups, commissions and parishes of the ASF. Pampanga Prelate and Forum Convenor, Abp. Paciano B. Aniceto, D.D. graced the event with Auxiliary Bishop and University of the Assumption President Roberto C. Mallari.

Apu Ceto, as Abp. Aniceto is fondly called, noted that the recount “is a secular process and the church will respect it”. He challenged the laity to take the lead in secular matters. He, likewise, challenged Panlilio’s supporters to sustain their involvement and accompany him as he confronts this issue.

For his part, Fr. Francis Dizon, Executive Director of the Social Action Center of Pampanga and PPCRV-Pampanga Chairman, vowed to give the public factual information on the progress of the recount/revision. He revealed PPCRV-Pampanga’s Plan of Action which includes posting of observers to monitor the process and holding of an audience with Commissioner Nicodemo T. Ferrer of the COMELEC 2nd Division every Wednesday for regular updates on the status of the recount. These updates will be posted on the following websites: www.rcasf.com; www.sacop.org.ph ; www.ppcrvnamfrel.blogspot.com; www.hrp-sac.blogspot.com; and www.parokya-santalucia.org.

The physical recount (e.g. sorting and segregation of ballots) is expected to be accomplished in 45 days starting August 12, 2009, after the Supreme Court ordered the COMELEC to proceed with it. Commissioner Sarmiento emphasized, though, that the battle does not end with the revision. After the COMELEC 2nd Division issues a resolution on the case, any of the parties can file a motion for reconsideration – a move which can wind up to the Supreme Court before the decision becomes final and executory.

Bp. Bobet Mallari delivered the closing remarks and reiterated the call to “offer ourselves as sacrificial lambs” and “to inquire and observe - for truth to triumph and the will of God to shine brightly”. Earlier during the open forum, 73-year old Lucila Valdez of Angeles City pledged to help start a fundraising campaign with a 10-centavo contribution to help the beleaguered Governor pay for his revisors.

It may be recalled that Panlilio recently filed a motion for the halting of the recount due to lack of funds to pay for his revisors. On the other hand, petitioner Lilia Pineda paid the P 4M plus deposit in August 2007 and provided trucks to haul the ballot boxes to the COMELEC warehouse in Manila for the recount. Panlilio’s motion was junked by the COMELEC.

Understanding the Recount Process

Understanding the Recount Process

Contrary to a popular notion that the recount involves a simple re-counting and re-tallying of votes, what Commissioner Sarmiento described was a long process of checking and validating results. Applied to the Pineda vs. Panlilio case, the recount process is as follows:

Timeline of the Case

• On May 25, 2007, defeated candidate Lilia Pineda through her legal counsel, Atty. George Garcia filed an election protest against Gov. Panlilio on allegations of: a) mis-appreciation and misreading of ballots and b) fraud and irregularities such as massive cheating, vote-buying and harassment of teachers and pollwatchers of the rival camp;

• Pineda’s petition specifically asked for a recount, where misread or misappreciated votes were to be counted in favor of Pineda. All ballot boxes from all the polling precincts in Pampanga (except Angeles City) were to be brought to Manila for the recount. In the event that the recount will yield a result favorable to her, Pineda has asked the COMELEC to proclaim her as Governor and annul the proclamation of Gov. Panlilio.

• Gov. Panlilio, through his legal team, filed a counter-protest on June 12, 2007 followed by a Motion to set Affirmative Defenses for Dismissal of Petition on July 2, a move that was denied by the COMELEC on July 23, 2007.

• Gov. Panlilio’s legal team filed a Motion for Reconsideration on July 31, 2007. The division’s presiding commissioner, Florentino Tuason Jr., dismissed the motion on August 1, 2007 and issued a notice of order to do the recount and revision. Pineda issued a check dated July 31, 2007 in the amount of P4,000,886.00 as deposit for the revision.

• A legal battle ensued and the issue was elevated to the Supreme Court (SC). The SC En Banc, on July 15, 2009, ordered the COMELEC to proceed with the recount. The process started on August 12, 2009 with a 45-day timeframe for its completion.

Recount Process

• Twenty one (21) Revision Committees, each consisting of six (6) revisors were constituted. All the ballot boxes from the province’s twenty towns and one city (City of San Fernando) were brought to Manila and distributed among the twenty one revision committees

• On the first day of the revision, the ballot custodian opened the ballot boxes and observed the condition of these boxes and their contents (taking note of the serial number, the condition of the padlocks and inner seal, and the documents contained therein). The observations were noted in the minutes of the proceedings.

• The ballots were segregated according to vote (per candidate – Panlilio, Pineda, Lapid and Stray Votes). Stray votes include those earlier declared as null and void (e.g. name of candidate not written on the proper space; name written on the ballot not accepted initially such as Nanay for Baby Pineda or Among for Gov. Panlilio).

• As the process progresses, ballots with Pineda votes are given to the revisors of Panlilio and ballots with Panlilio votes are given to the revisors of Pineda. It is up to the revisors to validate and register any objection (e.g. presence of unnecessary markings, etc.). It is also up to the revisors to claim votes for the candidate they are representing or contest the votes of the opponent. Objections and claims are noted down, collated and submitted to the Chairperson of each revision committee who is tasked to prepare a revision report for the precinct/cluster of precincts assigned to his/her committee.

• The revision is expected to be finished by September 2009 following the 45-day timeframe set by the COMELEC. After the revision, all reports will be collated by the counsels of both parties and will be offered as evidence to the 2nd Division of COMELEC.

• The 2nd Division will study the reports and in the event of any doubt on the veracity of these reports will go back and examine the ballots for validation. After studying the revision reports, the 2nd Division will issue a resolution.

• After the 2nd Division issues a resolution, any of the contesting parties can file a motion for reconsideration. In this eventuality, the case is to be elevated to the COMELEC en banc and raffled off among the COMELEC Commissioners, one of who will be responsible for deciding whether to sustain or to reject the resolution. In case of a tie in the voting on the case, the COMELEC Chairman will break the tie.

• After the COMELEC en banc’s decision is issued, the losing party can file a petition for certiorari with the Supreme Court which will make the final decision on the matter.

The public is advised to stop believing in unfounded claims that this or that candidate is gaining edge over his/her rival. Results of the recount/revision will not be final until after the resolution is issued by the COMELEC En Banc (and Supreme Court En Banc if the case is elevated to the SC). Factual information from PPCRV (which coordinates directly with the COMELEC 2nd Division in monitoring the recount process) can be accessed at the following websites: www.rcasf.com; www.sacop.org.ph ; www.ppcrvnamfrel.blogspot.com; www.hrp-sac.blogspot.com; and www.parokya-santalucia.org or call the PPCRV-Pampanga Secretariat at tel. nos. 860-53-38 or 961-41-12.